A fellow baker and blogger, Kyleen, posted a while back about how she used to fear Vanilla Cupcakes and I know 100% how that feels. I never was a big fan of plain vanilla cupcakes; they're sweet and seem almost shallow - there's no unexpected hit that comes with it or any acquired appreciation of the taste. Unlike the Red Velvet Cupcake, Vanilla Cupcakes don't carry a second subtle flavour that keeps you guessing. It also doesn't throw you off with a entirely different tasting frosting either. It's just sweet and sugar.
And I suppose that's where my newfound appreciation for Vanilla Cupcakes has slowly grown from. They almost seem like starting a plain palette - what can I add to it, where can subtlety stem from, how can I kick it up a notch, how can I throw the taster off? Mind you, I'm still not a big fan of the 'just sugar' taste but I can appreciate how it melds with other flavours so well.
My personal fear of Vanilla Cupcakes came from the difficulty I've always had with them. I was always so envious of people who would just make cupcakes from the Betty Crocker mixes - they'd have perfect cupcakes (albeit too sweet) in 20 minutes and be able to say 'yeah, I made vanilla cupcakes', whereas I would be sitting at home mixing and beating and baking and I'd still end up with stiff and dry cupcakes.
I was thinking about this on my walk home today as I was passing by an Indigo, the bookstore near my apartment. I wasn't actually intending on going to the cookbooks section but I always end up there. I went to the cakes section, found the Magnolia Bakery cookbook (one of the preeminent cupcake bakeries out there who gave cupcakes their reputation and fan-base), and went to the helpful tips for cakes section. Their biggest tip was making sure you beat the butter and sugar mixture for 3-4 minutes so it actually accumulated size and turned pale.
I also opened up a couple more cookbooks, even some unrelated ones (William Sonoma's cookbook for pies & tarts, oh my), read through all the tips, and went home ready to tackle the elusive vanilla cupcake again.
And every time I bake, I remember how the thing I love most about baking is how complicated it is - most of the time it's really not about just throwing ingredients together and following a recipe. It's about how you bake it, why you're baking, and how much you're willing to listen to what you're baking. It's also not always about the recipe, it's the method.
These cupcakes were amazing. My roommate and I literally could not stop eating them - they are the lightest cupcakes I've ever eaten, lighter than the ones made from mix or in the stores (that's right), and I'm overjoyed. The thing you want/need to pay attention to with the classic vanilla cupcake recipe is the times for everything. Where I always went wrong time after time was not reading the times carefully - I never let my butter and sugar get fluffy like they were supposed to because I merely beat them to mix evenly instead of beating them to gain size and become light.
Kyleen gave me the vanilla cupcake recipe she used here so I'll share it with you all (makes 12):
- 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons flour
- 2 tablespoons cornstarch
- 1 ½ teaspoons baking powder
- 1/8 teaspoon salt
- ½ cup unsalted butter, at room temperature
- ¾ cup granulated sugar
- 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
- 2 large eggs, at room temperature
- ½ cup milk or sour cream, at room temperature
Preheat your oven to 350 F first-off.
In one bowl, sift together your flour, cornstarch, baking powder, and salt.
In a second bowl, beat your room temperature butter with your mixer at medium-high for about 30 seconds to a minute. You want it to start paling and get fluffy.
Continue beating on low-medium and pour in your sugar, a bit at a time.
This is where you want to spend a lot of your time. Add in your egg and beat for 3-4 minutes on medium. Literally watch a clock and make sure you've hit at least 3 minutes.
 |
| It gets into this scrambled egg look but it'll go away as soon as you start whipping! |
 |
| 3-4 minutes later, it turns into this gorgeous fluffy goodness |
You'll notice your mixture turning pale and very fluffy, almost doubling in size. This is what's called creaming. This is basically your secret to fluffy and lighter cupcakes.
Fold in the dry with the wet ingredients carefully. Make sure you are not beating or whisking the mixtures together, you don't want everything you just did go to waste. Fold until well mixed.
Add in your milk and vanilla extract, fold in some more, and you're good to go.
Scoop into your cupcake tray, bake for 20-25 minutes, and let cool for 30 minutes to an hour.
For the icing, you can choose any. I've cited before on another post: here's a Swiss Meringue Buttercream recipe and here's a typical Vanilla Buttercream or American Buttercream recipe.
That's it. Simple and delightful, enjoy!
Troubleshooting:
Q: Your batter's ending up stiff and dry when you bake it?
A: Be sure that your butter and eggs were at room temperature prior to baking. If they were, be sure that when 'creaming', you let the butter, eggs, and sugar beat for at least 3 minutes.
Q: I did all that and it still ended up stiff and dry?
A: You probably over-baked it or over-added your dry ingredients. Make sure your dry ingredients are to measure and that you check at the 20-minute mark whether they're done or not. Every oven's different and some can be off by almost 25 F. Gauge a good idea of where your cupcakes are at at 20-minutes and check again in 2-3 minutes.
Additional questions, comments, or concerns? Shoot them below! Thanks.
- Jane
